Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Reciprocal Accountability

I think the idea of "reciprocal accountability" is a breath of fresh air.

I think educators should go further and set up reciprocal accountability at a local, state and national level.  For example,  teacher effectiveness should be correlated to a range of factors that are informed by students' SES.  What is society doing (via a local, state or national infrastructures) to foster the conditions that will help teachers be more effective?  Suggestions include:
  1. Children are well-rested and well-fed.
  2. Children have opportunities for quiet-time to reflect about their learning and/or do homework.
  3. Children have safe and numerous opportunities to play/participate in recreation outside of the school environment.
  4. Children have access to fully-funded libraries with fully-supported technology.
  5. Children have access to school facilities and programs, via public funding, that reflect those in wealthy independent schools.
  6. Teacher:student ratios reflect those of highly successful independent schools (after all, if it's good enough for wealthy kids, it should be good enough for poor kids).
  7. Children have access to full healthcare.
  8. Children's families have access to home ownership and job counseling.
Susan Moore Johnson, John Papay, Randi Weingarten and W. James Popham all refer to the acute impact of SES on effective teaching.  Give urban or very rural teachers these pre-conditions and we will reciprocate!

Saturday, March 13, 2010

"Teacher Effectiveness" & Self-Assessment

I don't think you can assess teacher effectiveness through students' test scores.  Standardized state tests  assess student effectiveness --- at taking tests. 

Alternatively, I would like "teacher effectiveness" to be a reflection of my ability to:

  • Cultivate safe classrooms (physically, emotionally, intellectually)
  • Advise and mentor individual and groups of students
  • [Re-]organize curricula to meet students' interests
  • Vary instruction and assessment to address students' needs
  • Communicate with colleagues, families, school partners
  • Design professional development that enriches the above criteria
  If you could design the criteria for your own "teacher effectiveness," what would it look like?

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Teacher Effectiveness and Reciprocal Accountability

According to an article in the Washington Post (Mar 2, 2010), President Barack Obama has condoned the mass firing of teachers at Central Falls High School, one of RI's poorest high schools:

"If a school continues to fail its students year after year after year, if it doesn't show signs of improvement, then there's got to be a sense of accountability," he said. "And that's what happened in Rhode Island last week at a chronically troubled school, when just 7 percent of 11th-graders passed state math tests -- 7 percent." 
-Barack Obama

Of course such low scores on the state's math tests are sad.  However, before we conclude that the teachers are accountable for such low scores, we should consider the issue of reciprocal accountability.  Specifically, we can ask what kinds of supports were in place to make sure that teachers could be effective.  If teachers are going to be accountable for student achievement, then teachers can require that schools, LEAs and state education departments provide the context for student achievement.*

Within schools, reciprocal accountability can mean many things.  Most importantly, teachers need to have the time to co-plan and influence school-wide policies.  I wonder if Central Falls had any reciprocal accountability in place?

Questions to consider with regard to reciprocal accountability:
  • Professional development (PD):  Are teachers involved in creating and facilitating their own PD?  Teachers are in a perfect position to align district priorities with the interests and needs of their students.  Why not create working groups in which teachers run PD alongside school and district administrators?
  • School Climate: Are teachers examining the research on school climate and then developing policy that matches their school's needs?
  • Assessment:  Arguably sub-set of PD, teachers could be looking at a variety of assessments that help them know how students are growing academically - - - and socially.  Everything from state-level standardized tests, district-mandated tests, formal and informal assessment, portfolios, rubrics and project-based learning should be up for discussion.  Each of these has a profound impact on how teachers organize their curricula and how students experience their learning.  
    By providing time for teachers to reflect and co-plan,  schools and districts will be providing one aspect of reciprocal accountability. What does reciprocal accountability look like to you?

    * Up next: considering society's reciprocal accountability to teachers.

    Thursday, February 25, 2010

    Assessing Teacher Effectiveness

    How do we know if a teacher is "good" or "effective?"

    Part of the national discussion is (has been) "teacher accountability."  According to both No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top, assessment of teachers should be associated with overall student growth.  Should teachers be held accountable for student learning?  If so, how does one measure student learning?

    HERE* is an interesting animation that contrasts an "attainment model" of assessing learning --- i.e. how much a child grows over time, vs. a "value-added model" --- i.e. how measurements of child growth are adjusted for environmental variables.  Just think of your student as a tree - - - .

    How do you want to be assessed as a teacher?

    * (Thanks to CTQ's Ali Kliegman for sharing this resource.)

    What am I, a bowling ball?

    I believe that professional development (PD) is most effective when teachers have a clear understanding of the larger issues: What's at stake?  Administrators (building, district or county) often make the mistake of not cultivating teachers' shared understanding of the larger issues.  Teachers therefore do not see how the PD is linked to student engagement, personal growth, or pedagogical concept development.

    I recently received an email indicating that district administrators were going to "...do professional development to teachers."  What am I, a bowling ball?!?

    Sunday, February 14, 2010

    What is meaningful assessment?

    How do we know children are learning? Do we have to use standardized tests, or are their other ways to make this determination?

    In a recent New York Times Op-ed (Feb 2, 2010; Op-Ed. p A23), Susan Engel, director of the teaching program at Williams College, discusses several important components of assessing student learning: reading, writing, computation, pattern detection, conversation and collaboration. Why not develop criteria that assess these skills (or broader, school-based values) as a measure of student learning?

    If we assess these broad skills, rather than merely test-taking skills, Engel believes that we will cultivate our students' long-term success. Engel argues that if students are able to demonstrate these skills (by age 12), then "...they would be prepared to learn almost anything in high school or college." While teachers can collaborate on the specifics of the curriculum, Engel has anchored the discussion of student assessment in values, i.e. what is it we value in public education.

    According to Engel, one value is raising children rather than raising test scores. Rather than measuring factory-like outputs via a "...curriculum that is strangling students and teachers alike...," she wants educators and policy-makers to consider their process values, i.e. what experiences students and teachers could have.

    At Science Leadership Academy (SLA) where I teach, we organize our curriculum around 5 core values that integrate of focus our learning (see Fig. 1 below). Although these criteria are not the same as Ms. Engel's, perhaps we need to extend some flexibility to schools to determine their own values that meet their specific students' and teachers' needs and interests. Once these values are in place, perhaps we can develop meaningful assessments that reflect students' and teachers' relation to the values.

    Fig. 1: SLA's Core Value & sample assessment criteria
    CORE VALUE SAMPLE ASSESSMENT CRITERIA
    Inquiry Student demonstrates a variety of strategies to frame questions about, and investigate, the fictional and non-fictional world.
    Research Student demonstrates a variety of strategies to gather and organize information.
    Collaboration Student demonstrates a variety of strategies to work with and learn from a variety of people.
    Presentation Student demonstrates a variety of strategies to share learning with a wider audience beyond the teacher.
    Reflection Student demonstrates a variety of strategies to modify and enrich the learning process and outcomes.

    Saturday, February 13, 2010

    Democracy & Educational Leadership

    What is it that makes an effective educational leader? Of course we need leaders who can help reform and enrich education --- but to what end? NYTimes columnist Bob Herbert may have some answers.

    There's one major problem with Bob Herbert's perspective on educational leadership. He assumes that public eduction exists to advance our country's international economic prowess ("In Search of Education Leaders," Dec 5, 2009). Alternatively, public education exists to cultivate democracy.

    A vibrant economy is certainly a worthy goal for any society, but it is democracy that helps individuals make smart choices that advance the common good---both locally and globally. This lesson can be learned at home and in our schools. Yet public education should represent our civil commitment to a democracy that fosters liberty and equality. Worthwhile educational reform requires leadership that is guided by such a democracy.

    As Ariel Sacks writes, we should also be careful about programs for educational leadership that are not explicitly linked to classroom teaching. Teachers make hundreds of decisions that help students navigate the complexities of democracy, i.e. the aligment of personal liberties with social equality. Without this direct experience of teaching and learning, what kind of reform can educational leaders provide?